# Ask better “why” questions: a teaching move with strong evidence

- Link: https://arqiv.si/ai-plainly-2026-10-27/
- Published: 2026-10-26T07:57:29-04:00
- Author: Steven Ryan

Hi there,

This week: one kind of question that helps students understand, not just remember,
a free coding tool from MIT, and the AI term you will hear most this year. Five 
minutes, start to finish.

### This issue in one minute

 * **Teaching method:** asking “why?” and “what if?” questions, and having students
   answer them, helps build deeper understanding. The U.S. Institute of Education
   Sciences rates this evidence “strong.”
 * **Tool of the week:** Scratch, free block-based coding from MIT.
 * **Word to know:** “generative AI,” AI that makes new text, pictures or sound.
 * **Try this on Monday:** a 10-minute “why or what-if?” activity with no devices.

---

### Teaching method spotlight

## Deep questions: ask “why?” and “what if?”

**What it is:** A deep question is one that needs an explanation for an answer, 
not a single fact. “Who signed the treaty?” has a one-word answer. “Why did the 
countries agree to it?” does not. The Institute of Education Sciences (IES), the
research arm of the U.S. Department of Education, lists question types that prompt
deep explanations: “why, why-not, how, what-if, how does X compare to Y, and what
is the evidence for X?”

**Why it works:** IES says a deep explanation is one that points to causes, plans,
reasoned arguments and logic. Answering these questions makes students put ideas
together instead of just repeating them. In its practice guide _Organizing Instruction
and Study to Improve Student Learning_, IES rates the evidence for this advice as“
strong.” That is the top of its three levels (strong, moderate, low). IES says it
is based on over a dozen experiments in K-12 classrooms, plus more with college 
students. It also says the advice fits once students already “have acquired a basic
set of knowledge” about a topic, so use it after the basics are taught.

> **What it means for you:** Pick one fact you plan to teach this week and turn 
> it into a “why” or “what-if” question. Ask it out loud, give students a minute
> to think, and ask a few to explain their answers. Then try having students write
> their own deep questions about what you just taught.

_Source: [What Works Clearinghouse practice guide, “Organizing Instruction and Study to Improve Student Learning”](https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/PracticeGuide/1)(
Recommendation 7), U.S. Institute of Education Sciences, September 2007._

---

### Tool of the week

## Scratch: free coding with blocks

**What it is:** With Scratch, students “program your own interactive stories, games,
and animations,” in Scratch’s words. Students snap blocks together instead of typing
code. Scratch is a project of the Lifelong Kindergarten Group at the MIT Media Lab.

**Cost:** free. Scratch says it is “provided free of charge.”

**Who it’s for:** Scratch says it is “designed especially for ages 8 to 16, but 
is used by people of all ages.”

**Accounts and privacy:** Scratch Foundation says its Teacher Accounts “make it 
easy for educators to create accounts for their students.” We did not read Scratch’s
privacy policy this week, so we can’t tell you what student data it collects. Read
it before you sign students up.

 1. Open [scratch.mit.edu](https://scratch.mit.edu/) and try the editor yourself first.
 2. Make a small project, such as a character that moves when you press a key.
 3. Decide whether students will use accounts, and check your district’s rules first.

> **What it means for you:** You do not need to know how to code. Spend 15 minutes
> on it before you introduce it, and ask your technology coordinator whether your
> district allows it.

_Sources: [About Scratch](https://scratch.mit.edu/help/about/) (MIT) and [Scratch Foundation, For Educators](https://www.scratchfoundation.org/learn/for-educators).
Quotes are Scratch’s own descriptions._

---

### Word to know

## “Generative AI”

**Generative AI** is AI that creates new text, images, audio or video, rather than
just sorting or labeling things. A chatbot that writes a paragraph and a program
that draws a picture from a description are both generative AI.

**Say it to students like this:** “It makes something new from patterns it learned.
That doesn’t mean what it makes is true.”

---

### Try this on Monday

## Why or what-if? (10 minutes, grades 4–12, no devices)

 1. **Pick:** choose one idea students just learned, such as a historical event, a 
    science rule or a math step.
 2. **Ask:** write one “why” question and one “what-if” question about it on the board.
 3. **Think:** give everyone one quiet minute, then let pairs talk for two minutes.
 4. **Share:** call on two or three pairs. Ask, “What is your evidence?”
 5. **Switch:** next time, have pairs write their own why and what-if questions.

For lessons built around thinking before using AI, see ARQIV’s [Think-First](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/)
lessons.

---

### Safety check

## Before students sign up for anything

 1. **Check your district’s approved-tools list** before you ask students to make an
    account on any site, Scratch included.
 2. **Share as little student information as you can.** Never put student names, grades
    or IEP details into an AI tool.
 3. **Read the privacy page** of any new tool. If you can’t find answers, ask your 
    technology coordinator.

---

### From ARQIV

 * [Think-First](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/): lessons that put student
   thinking before AI.
 * [Free AI lesson](https://arqiv.si/teachers/free-ai-lesson/): a complete lesson
   you can use right away.

---

### Your turn

Hit reply and tell us: **what’s the best “why” question you’ve ever asked a class?**
A real person reads every reply.

See you next week,
The ARQIV team
