# The Think-First guide

- Link: https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/
- Published: 2026-10-02T21:06:56-04:00
- Author: Steven Ryan

[Skip to content](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/#main-content)

[arqiv](https://arqiv.si/)

[For educators](https://arqiv.si/teachers/)

Teach

 * [Start here](https://arqiv.si/teachers/)
 * [Lessons & printable kits](https://arqiv.si/teachers/resources/)
 * [Classroom labs](https://arqiv.si/teachers/labs/)
 * [Free 20-minute lesson](https://arqiv.si/teachers/free-ai-lesson/)

Plan

 * [Curriculum guide](https://arqiv.si/teachers/curriculum/)
 * [AI Learning Center](https://arqiv.si/teachers/ai-literacy/)
 * [Future of work unit](https://arqiv.si/future-of-work/)
 * [What the research says](https://arqiv.si/teachers/what-works/)
 * [AI education worldwide](https://arqiv.si/teachers/around-the-world/)

Understand

 * [Think First method](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/)
 * [Our approach](https://arqiv.si/research/#our-method)
 * [AI vocabulary](https://arqiv.si/teachers/ai-vocabulary/)

By role

 * [Counselors](https://arqiv.si/counselors/)
 * [School leaders & PD](https://arqiv.si/schools/)
 * [Speaking & workshops](https://arqiv.si/speaking/)
 * [Products](https://arqiv.si/products/)

[Learn AI](https://arqiv.si/ai/topics/)

Start

 * [All AI topics](https://arqiv.si/ai/topics/)
 * [The AI journey, from zero](https://arqiv.si/ai/)
 * [Using AI well](https://arqiv.si/ai/talking-to-ai/)
 * [AI builds](https://arqiv.si/ai-builds/)

AI in the world

 * [Space](https://arqiv.si/space/)
 * [Weather](https://arqiv.si/weather/)
 * [Health](https://arqiv.si/health/)
 * [Engineering](https://arqiv.si/engineering/)
 * [Farming](https://arqiv.si/farming/)
 * [Quantum](https://arqiv.si/quantum/)

What it means

 * [Future of work](https://arqiv.si/future-of-work/)
 * [Your AI path](https://arqiv.si/ai/your-path/)
 * [Research, explained](https://arqiv.si/research/)

[Games & labs](https://arqiv.si/games/)[Research](https://arqiv.si/research/)[Blog](https://arqiv.si/blog/)
[About](https://arqiv.si/about/)

[Search or ask](https://arqiv.si/ai/topics/)[Newsletter](https://arqiv.si/newsletter/)
[ARQIV.FM ↗](https://arqiv.fm/)

Menu

For educators

[For educators: start page →](https://arqiv.si/teachers/)

Teach

 * [Start here](https://arqiv.si/teachers/)
 * [Lessons & printable kits](https://arqiv.si/teachers/resources/)
 * [Classroom labs](https://arqiv.si/teachers/labs/)
 * [Free 20-minute lesson](https://arqiv.si/teachers/free-ai-lesson/)

Plan

 * [Curriculum guide](https://arqiv.si/teachers/curriculum/)
 * [AI Learning Center](https://arqiv.si/teachers/ai-literacy/)
 * [Future of work unit](https://arqiv.si/future-of-work/)
 * [What the research says](https://arqiv.si/teachers/what-works/)
 * [AI education worldwide](https://arqiv.si/teachers/around-the-world/)

Understand

 * [Think First method](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/)
 * [Our approach](https://arqiv.si/research/#our-method)
 * [AI vocabulary](https://arqiv.si/teachers/ai-vocabulary/)

By role

 * [Counselors](https://arqiv.si/counselors/)
 * [School leaders & PD](https://arqiv.si/schools/)
 * [Speaking & workshops](https://arqiv.si/speaking/)
 * [Products](https://arqiv.si/products/)

Learn AI

[Learn AI: start page →](https://arqiv.si/ai/topics/)

Start

 * [All AI topics](https://arqiv.si/ai/topics/)
 * [The AI journey, from zero](https://arqiv.si/ai/)
 * [Using AI well](https://arqiv.si/ai/talking-to-ai/)
 * [AI builds](https://arqiv.si/ai-builds/)

AI in the world

 * [Space](https://arqiv.si/space/)
 * [Weather](https://arqiv.si/weather/)
 * [Health](https://arqiv.si/health/)
 * [Engineering](https://arqiv.si/engineering/)
 * [Farming](https://arqiv.si/farming/)
 * [Quantum](https://arqiv.si/quantum/)

What it means

 * [Future of work](https://arqiv.si/future-of-work/)
 * [Your AI path](https://arqiv.si/ai/your-path/)
 * [Research, explained](https://arqiv.si/research/)

 * [Games & labs](https://arqiv.si/games/)
 * [Research](https://arqiv.si/research/)
 * [Blog](https://arqiv.si/blog/)
 * [About](https://arqiv.si/about/)

[Get the newsletter](https://arqiv.si/newsletter/)

[Start here](https://arqiv.si/teachers/)[Lessons & kits](https://arqiv.si/teachers/resources/)
[Curriculum](https://arqiv.si/teachers/curriculum/)[Labs](https://arqiv.si/teachers/labs/)
[Think First](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/)[AI vocabulary](https://arqiv.si/teachers/ai-vocabulary/)
[For schools](https://arqiv.si/schools/)[Counselors](https://arqiv.si/counselors/)

The Think-First guide

# Students think. _AI assists._ Students own it.

A practical guide for teachers, counselors and school leaders: how to structure 
lessons, set AI rules and design assignments so students learn to work with AI without
handing it their thinking.

[Classroom AI agreement](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/#agreement)

On this page

 1. [Why we can’t just catch it](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/#why)
 2. [The 5 P’s in detail](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/#ps)
 3. [AI use levels for every assignment](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/#levels)
 4. [Assessment that rewards thinking](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/#assess)
 5. [Classroom AI agreement & AI receipt](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/#agreement)
 6. [Questions teachers ask](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/#faq)

1 · The problem

## Why we can’t _just catch it_

**AI detectors don’t work well enough to grade by.** OpenAI shut down its own AI-
text detector in 2023 because of its “low rate of accuracy.” A Stanford-led study
in the journal _Patterns_ found popular detectors wrongly flagged more than half
of essays written by non-native English speakers as AI-generated.

**Bans protect thinking but leave a gap.** Handwritten work and in-class tests are
worth keeping. But students still meet AI at home, and they’ll meet it at work. 
If school never teaches them how to use it well, someone else will teach them how
to use it badly.

**Design assignments well instead of trying to catch students.** When the grade 
comes from a student’s questions, plans, critiques and spoken explanations, copying
from AI stops being useful. You don’t need to police the product if you’re assessing
the process.

2 · The method

## The 5 P’s, _in detail_

Use this structure for any assignment where AI is allowed. It works for a 45-minute
lesson or a three-week project.

1

### Ponder

○ Screens off

**Students think before anything else touches the problem.** They ask questions,
list ideas, sketch, estimate, recall what they know and notice what they don’t.

 * **Teacher moves:** pose an open question; require a written first answer before
   discussion; use think-pair-share.
 * **Good prompts for students:** What do I already know? What would a good answer
   look like? What am I unsure about? What are three possibilities?
 * **Evidence of thinking:** handwritten notes, sketches, estimates and first answers,
   collected or photographed.

2

### Plan

○ Screens off

**Students turn their thinking into something precise:** a brief, a hypothesis, 
a principle, a thesis, success criteria. This is where clear communication is learned,
and it’s exactly what makes AI useful later.

 * **Teacher moves:** give a template (see the briefs in each lesson); have partners
   test whether a plan is clear enough to act on.
 * **Why it matters:** students who can say exactly what they need get far better
   results, from AI and from people.

3

### Partner

● AI on · short & structured

**AI is brought in for one specific job**, named in advance: generate options, argue
the other side, give feedback, explain a concept a different way, or produce a draft
to critique.

 * **No student devices?** Run it on the teacher’s screen. The class decides what
   to ask; one person types; everyone takes notes.
 * **Ask for options, not answers.** “Give me three ways…” teaches more than “What’s
   the answer?”
 * **Keep a receipt.** Students record every prompt and what came back.

4

### Probe

○ Screens off

**Students interrogate what AI produced.** This is the core AI literacy skill, and
one that many adults have never practiced.

 * What did it get right? What is wrong, missing or invented?
 * Is it generic or cliché? Did it make assumptions (about people, places, values)?
 * Did it agree too easily? (Next time, ask it to argue the opposite during Partner.)
 * Check one claim against a real source.

5

### Prove

○ Screens off

**Students make the final work their own and defend it.** They revise by hand, then
explain their choices in writing or out loud.

 * **Two-minute defense:** “Walk me through why you made this choice.” A clear explanation
   is evidence of understanding, not proof of authorship: read it alongside drafts
   and the transfer task, and don’t treat success or difficulty alone as proof.
 * **Transfer task:** solve a twin problem or write a short response with no AI.
 * **Reflection:** what I kept from AI, what I rejected, and why.

3 · Clear rules

## AI use levels for _every assignment_

Label every assignment with a level so students never have to guess what’s allowed.
Adapted from the AI Assessment Scale developed by Perkins, Furze, Roe and MacVaugh.

**Level 0** No AI

Show what you can do on your own. Handwritten, in class.

Example: in-class essay, unit test, reading response, the “Prove” step.

**Level 1** AI after thinking

AI only after you’ve done your own thinking, to test or challenge it. Your ideas
come first.

Example: argue with AI after writing your thesis; compare your solution with AI’s.

**Level 2** AI as feedback

AI can give feedback or questions on your own draft. It doesn’t write for you.

Example: “What’s the weakest part of my argument?” on a draft you wrote.

**Level 3** AI as collaborator

AI can help create parts of the work, from your brief. You document everything and
own the final choices.

Example: AI concept art from your character brief, revised by you.

**Level 4** AI exploration

The assignment is about exploring what AI can do: testing it, breaking it, comparing
tools.

Example: an “AI lab” investigation of where image generators show bias.

Our levels are numbered 0–4. If your school already uses the AIAS (levels 1–5), 
note that our Level 4 “AI exploration” means studying AI itself, and we leave out
the AIAS “Full AI” level. The [AI Assessment Scale (AIAS)](https://aiassessmentscale.com/)
by Mike Perkins, Leon Furze, Jasper Roe and Jason MacVaugh is licensed under [CC BY-NC-SA 4.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/).
Our level names, numbering and examples are adapted from it.

4 · Assessment

## Grade the _thinking_

Six simple ways to make the process visible and the product less important.

Thinking first, on paper

### Collect the Ponder page

Grade the handwritten first ideas, questions and estimates. They show where the 
thinking started.

Two-minute defense

### Talk it through

A short conversation (“Why this flaw? Why this source?”) gives evidence of understanding
and builds speaking skills. Pair it with drafts and an accessible independent task;
struggling to answer on the spot does not by itself prove AI misuse.

AI receipts

### Show your prompts

Students attach every prompt, what came back, and what they kept or rejected. Honesty
becomes part of the assignment.

Critique counts

### Grade the Probe

Reward students for finding AI’s mistakes, gaps and biases. It’s analytical thinking,
the skill employers rank highest (WEF Future of Jobs Report 2025), applied to AI.

Versions

### Draft → AI → final

Compare drafts. Growth between versions shows learning; a perfect first draft with
no history raises a question.

Transfer tasks

### Twin problems

End with a short, AI-free task that uses the same skill. If they can do it alone,
they learned it.

5 · Templates

## Classroom AI agreement & _AI receipt_

Copy, edit and post these. Review the agreement with students and send it home to
families.

    ```
    OUR CLASSROOM AI AGREEMENT
    1. I think first. I write down my own ideas before I use AI.
    2. I check the level. Every assignment says how much AI is allowed (Level 0–4). If I’m not sure, I ask.
    3. I give AI a job and keep the thinking for myself. I ask for options, feedback or a counterargument, not for my answer.
    4. I keep receipts. I save every prompt I use and what came back.
    5. I question everything. AI can be wrong, biased or made up. I check at least one claim.
    6. I own my work. I can explain every choice in my own words.
    7. I protect privacy. I don’t share personal information about myself or others with AI tools.
    8. I follow the tool’s rules, including age requirements.
    Student signature: ____________________   Date: ________
    Family signature: _____________________
    ```

    ```
    AI RECEIPT  (attach to any assignment where AI was used)
    Assignment: ___________________________   AI level allowed: ____
    My thinking BEFORE AI (summarize your first ideas):
    Tool used: _____________   Date: _______
    Prompt 1:
    What came back (summary):
    What I kept and why:
    What I rejected and why:
    Prompt 2:
    What came back (summary):
    What I kept and why:
    What I rejected and why:
    One claim I checked, and where:
    In one sentence, what is MINE in this work?
    ```

6 · FAQ

## Questions teachers _ask us_

Short, practical answers.

Our school limits student screens. Can we still teach AI?

Yes. Every ARQIV lesson works with AI only on the teacher’s screen. Students do 
all their thinking, critiquing and defending on paper. Watching AI make mistakes
on a projector, and catching them as a class, is one of the most powerful AI literacy
lessons there is.

Should we use AI detectors?

We don’t recommend grading with them. Even OpenAI withdrew its detector for low 
accuracy, and research has shown detectors unfairly flag non-native English writers.
A short conversation about a student’s choices can provide evidence of understanding,
especially alongside drafts and an independent task. It is not proof of authorship,
and difficulty answering does not by itself prove AI misuse.

What if a student uses AI at home anyway?

Design so it doesn’t help much. If the grade comes from in-class Ponder notes, a
handwritten plan, a critique and a spoken defense, an AI-written final product earns
very little. And students who use AI with an honest receipt are learning exactly
what you want them to.

What about students under 13?

ARQIV materials are written for grades 6–12, and most sixth graders and many seventh
graders are under 13. Start unplugged: teach that AI finds patterns and makes predictions,
using sorting activities and the “guess the next word” game. Any AI use should be
teacher-led and on the teacher’s screen. Many AI tools require users to be at least
13, so check each tool’s age rules and your district’s policy.

Doesn’t this take more class time?

A little at first. But the Ponder and Plan phases are good teaching with or without
AI. You’re teaching questioning, planning and revision, skills that already sit 
in your standards. The AI step is usually 10–15 minutes.

Which AI tool should we use?

Use whatever your district has approved. The 5 P’s work with any chatbot or image
tool, because the skill we teach is the thinking students do around the tool. Tools
change every few months; the method doesn’t.

How does this prepare students for careers?

Employers increasingly need people who can define a problem clearly, direct AI tools,
catch their mistakes and take responsibility for the result. That’s Plan, Partner,
Probe and Prove. Our [AI in…](https://arqiv.si/space/) pages show real jobs where
people work with AI every day.

Sources for this guide

 * [OpenAI: AI classifier discontinued for low accuracy (update, July 2023)](https://openai.com/index/new-ai-classifier-for-indicating-ai-written-text/)
 * [Liang et al., “GPT detectors are biased against non-native English writers,” Patterns (2023)](https://www.cell.com/patterns/fulltext/S2666-3899(23)00130-7)
 * [The AI Assessment Scale (Perkins, Furze, Roe & MacVaugh), licensed CC BY-NC-SA 4.0](https://aiassessmentscale.com/)
 * [World Economic Forum, Future of Jobs Report 2025: Skills outlook](https://www.weforum.org/publications/the-future-of-jobs-report-2025/in-full/3-skills-outlook/)
 * George Pólya, _How to Solve It_ (1945)

[← Back**For teachers**](https://arqiv.si/teachers/)[First lesson →**The detective’s notebook**](https://arqiv.si/teachers/detectives-notebook/)

Put curiosity to work

## Read it. Try it. Question it.

Explore new AI research, or take a paper-first investigation into your classroom.

[Classroom starter pack →](https://arqiv.si/teachers/classroom-starter-pack/)[Research explained →](https://arqiv.si/research/)

[arqiv](https://arqiv.si/)

A little understanding changes everything.

[LISTEN: ARQIV.FM, OUR WEEKLY SHOW ↗](https://arqiv.fm/)

Educators

 * [Start here](https://arqiv.si/teachers/)
 * [Lessons & kits](https://arqiv.si/teachers/resources/)
 * [Curriculum](https://arqiv.si/teachers/curriculum/)
 * [Labs](https://arqiv.si/teachers/labs/)
 * [AI vocabulary](https://arqiv.si/teachers/ai-vocabulary/)

For your role

 * [Counselors](https://arqiv.si/counselors/)
 * [School leaders & PD](https://arqiv.si/schools/)
 * [Speaking & workshops](https://arqiv.si/speaking/)
 * [Products](https://arqiv.si/products/)

Learn

 * [Learn AI](https://arqiv.si/ai/topics/)
 * [Games & labs](https://arqiv.si/games/)
 * [Future of work](https://arqiv.si/future-of-work/)
 * [Research](https://arqiv.si/research/)
 * [Headlines](https://arqiv.si/news/)

ARQIV

 * [About & corrections](https://arqiv.si/about/)
 * [Our approach](https://arqiv.si/research/#our-method)
 * [Newsletter](https://arqiv.si/newsletter/)
 * [Privacy](https://arqiv.si/privacy-policy/)
 * [Get in touch](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/info@arqiv.fm)

Classroom activities collect no student data.[info@arqiv.fm](https://arqiv.si/teachers/think-first/info@arqiv.fm)
