Teach it · A second Think-First unit
Decide & Adapt
AI is taking over tasks, and the first changes are landing on entry-level work. What stays valuable is judgment (deciding well when you can’t know for sure) and agility (learning what nobody has taught you yet). These six lessons practice both with the same 5 P’s routine as the Think-First unit, in decision mode.
How to read this page
Evidence labels
Every claim carries a label. Documented means published research or an official document. Reported means a news outlet, survey or official source reports it. Suggestive / early means early or thin evidence, or a study that measured something narrower than the claim. Claimed means the person or company says it, with no independent check.
Six weeks
One lesson a week, one decision skill at a time
Use them in order as a unit, an advisory series or an “AI lab” block. Each lesson stands alone too.
The 60% Problem
Decide with missing factsWeek 2How Sure Are You?
Match confidence to evidenceWeek 3Kill the Plan
Find the failure before it happensWeek 4Same Bones
Borrow from another fieldWeek 5The Rules Just Changed
Change the plan, keep the pointWeek 6Learn It in a Period
Learn fast, teach it back| Week | Lesson | Skill | AI use | Evidence for the core move |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Week 1 | The 60% Problem | Judgment · information triage | Level 1 AI after thinking | Reported |
| Week 2 | How Sure Are You? | Judgment · calibration | Level 0 No AI | Documented · adult forecasters |
| Week 3 | Kill the Plan | Judgment · pre-mortem and second-order effects | Level 1 AI after thinking | Suggestive |
| Week 4 | Same Bones | Agility · transfer by comparing cases | Level 2 AI as feedback | Documented |
| Week 5 | The Rules Just Changed | Agility · re-planning when constraints change | Level 1 AI after thinking | Documented |
| Week 6 | Learn It in a Period | Agility · learning something new, then teaching it | Level 2 AI as feedback | Documented |
The method
The 5 P’s in decision mode
Not a new framework: the same five steps as the Think-First lessons, pointed at decisions instead of answers. Four of them happen with screens off.
Ponder
What do we know, and what don’t we know? List facts, gaps and questions. Pencil only.
○ Screens offPlan
Write your assumptions and a confidence number before you look anything up.
○ Screens offPartner
Use AI once, as a red team: “How could this go wrong?” Usually on the teacher’s screen.
● AI on · shortProbe
Stress-test the decision: a pre-mortem, a missing fact, a rule that changes.
○ Screens offProve
Write the decision memo or teach it back, and defend it out loud: “What would change my mind?”
○ Screens offAssessment
Grade the process, not the answer
Good decisions can turn out badly and lucky guesses can turn out well, so every rubric scores the thinking students show.
1 · Assumptions stated
Did students write down what they were treating as true, before checking?
2 · Information triage
Did they choose which missing facts were worth getting, and stop when more would not change the decision?
3 · Confidence vs. outcome
Did their stated confidence match how things turned out, across many decisions?
4 · Quality of the change
When facts or rules changed, did Version 2 keep what worked and fix what didn’t, for stated reasons?
| Criteria (preview) | 4 · Excellent | 3 · Solid | 2 · Developing | 1 · Beginning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Assumptions stated | Clear, written first, at least one tested | Written first | Vague or written after | None |
| Confidence vs. outcome | Confidence moves sensibly with evidence, explained | Start and end confidence given | A number without reasons | None |
Each lesson has its own four-row rubric. No letter grade is needed for the capstone.
Capstone
Prove it live
A three-minute public decision defense, not a seventh lesson.
How it works
- Each student or team takes a decision: a Black Box scenario, or a real school decision (a club budget, a schedule change, an event plan).
- They have three minutes to present: the choice, the top assumption, their confidence, the pre-mortem’s top risk and the fix, and what would change their mind.
- A panel of adults (teachers, a counselor, a local employer if one is available) asks two questions each and scores with the lesson rubrics.
Ground rules
- No letter grade required; written feedback from the panel instead.
- Judge the reasoning, not whether the decision turned out to be “right.”
- Count it toward the Challenge Chart (challenge 11).
- Students never need to share personal information.
Honest limits and sources
Where this comes from
Open the source before quoting it.
Honest limits
What this page leaves out
This is an initial edition, written by ARQIV in October 2026. The lessons have not yet been classroom-piloted or independently reviewed. The research labels in the table describe the core move each lesson borrows (comparing cases, confidence with feedback, trying before being taught), mostly studied with adults or in math and science, not these lessons themselves. Nothing in the unit measures or certifies “judgment” or “learning agility.”
Review status
Written by ARQIV. Initial edition, October 2026. The lessons have not been classroom-piloted or independently reviewed yet, and every question and scenario is hand-authored and checked against its sources by ARQIV. Tell us about anything wrong or unclear.
- Alliance for Decision Education, Decision Education Standards.
- Welton Chang, Eva Chen, Barbara Mellers and Philip Tetlock, "Developing expert political judgment," Judgment and Decision Making 11(5), 2016, pp. 509–526.
- Mitchell, Russo and Pennington (1989), as reviewed by Jason Collins, "Premortem"; Gary Klein, "Performing a Project Premortem," Harvard Business Review (2007).
- Jeffrey Loewenstein, Leigh Thompson and Dedre Gentner, "Analogical encoding facilitates knowledge transfer in negotiation," Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 6(4), 1999; see also Gentner, Loewenstein and Thompson, Journal of Educational Psychology 95(2), 2003.
- Tanmay Sinha and Manu Kapur, "When Problem Solving Followed by Instruction Works: Evidence for Productive Failure," Review of Educational Research 91(5), 2021.
- John Dunlosky and colleagues, “Improving Students’ Learning With Effective Learning Techniques,” Psychological Science in the Public Interest 14(1), 2013; Association for Psychological Science press release “Which Study Strategies Make the Grade?”.
All links opened and checked October 21, 2026 (accessed October 2026).