Decide & Adapt · Week 4 · Agility · transfer

Same Bones

Students compare two cases from different fields, name the principle they share, and use it to predict what happens in a third case.

Level 2 AI as feedbackGrades 8–12 (6–7 adaptation)45 minutesNone for students (optional Same Bones lab)

The big idea

Ideas travel when you compare two examples side by side, not when you study them one at a time.

Students will be able to:

  • Compare two cases and map their parts
  • Name a shared principle in plain words
  • Apply the principle to a new case
  • Explain why the analogy breaks somewhere

Lesson flow · the 5 P’s in decision mode

Think first. Then the tool.

Most of the lesson happens on paper. AI appears once, as a critic, and the teacher can run it from one screen. How the 5 P’s work in decision mode →

1

Ponder

8 min○ Screens off · paper only
  1. Pairs read Case A (the warehouse) and Case B (the passing period) side by side.
  2. Each pair lists what is similar and what is different.
Say to students“These two stories come from different worlds. Look for the skeleton underneath.”
2

Plan

10 min○ Screens off · paper only
  1. Pairs fill in a two-column map: “In the warehouse… / In the school…” for the crowd, the narrow point, the waiting and the fix.
  2. Each pair writes the shared principle in one sentence, without using either story’s words.
Say to students“If your principle mentions robots or lockers, it is too specific. Try again.”
3

Partner

7 min● AI on · teacher screen, optional
  1. Optional, Level 2 (AI as feedback), on the teacher’s screen: enter one pair’s principle and ask the AI for two more real-world cases with the same structure.
  2. The class judges each AI example: same bones, or only on the surface?
Here is a principle my class wrote: [principle]. Give me two real-world examples from different fields that share this exact structure, and one example that looks similar but does not.
Say to students“An AI can produce examples fast. Your job is to check they really share the structure.”
4

Probe

10 min○ Screens off · paper only
  1. Hand out Case C (the lunch line). Pairs predict what will happen if the school adds a second cashier but keeps one serving station.
  2. Pairs check their prediction against the principle and against each other.
Say to students“Where is the narrowest point? Fix that, or nothing else helps.”
5

Prove

10 min○ Screens off · paper only
  1. Alone: apply the principle to a fourth case of your choice (a school, a game, a sport, a website) and explain it in plain words.
  2. Add one place where the analogy breaks down.
Say to students“Every analogy breaks somewhere. Knowing where is part of understanding it.”

Materials

What you need

Everything here is hand-authored and fictional unless a source is named.

Checklist

  • Case cards A and B (below)
  • Case C card
  • Worksheet, one per student
  • Optional: the Same Bones lab for extra sets

Hand-authored example

Case cards (hand-authored, simplified)

  • Case A · The warehouse. In a robotic warehouse, robots carry shelves to people who pick items. At busy times, robots queue at one narrow aisle next to the packing area. Adding more robots makes the queue longer, not the work faster. Managers fix it by spreading shelves so fewer robots need that aisle, and by sending robots in waves.
  • Case B · The passing period. At a school, everyone changes classes at once. The stairwell by the cafeteria jams; students are late even though the halls elsewhere are empty. Adding a minute to passing time barely helps. The school fixes it by opening a second stairwell and staggering the bell for two grades by three minutes.
  • Case C · The lunch line (apply it). The cafeteria has one serving station and one cashier. The line is long. The school plans to add a second cashier. Predict: will the line get much shorter? Why or why not? What would you change instead?
  • Teacher key. Shared principle: a system can only move as fast as its narrowest point (its bottleneck); adding capacity anywhere else does little, while widening or bypassing the narrow point, or spreading arrivals over time, helps. Case C: if serving is slower than paying, a second cashier barely helps; add a second serving station or stagger lunch times.

Printable

Student worksheet

Print one per student. Everything students hand in is handwritten, so their thinking is visible.

Same Bones

Decide & Adapt · Week 4. Write your own thinking; it is what gets graded.

Name:Date:Class:
1 · Case A and Case B: three things that are alike
2 · Map the parts: in the warehouse… / in the school…
3 · The shared principle, in one sentence, without the stories’ words
4 · Case C: my prediction and why
5 · A fourth case of my own, explained with the principle
6 · Where the analogy breaks down

Assessment

Grade the process, not the answer

Every row scores something students did themselves. A lucky answer with no reasoning scores low; a careful decision that turned out wrong can score high.

Criteria4 · Excellent3 · Solid2 · Developing1 · Beginning
MappingMaps every key part and names a difference that mattersMaps the main parts correctlyMaps surface features (both are crowded)No mapping
PrincipleGeneral, accurate and in plain wordsAccurate but tied to one storyPartly accurateMissing
Transfer to Case CCorrect prediction, explained with the principle, and a better fixCorrect prediction with a reasonPrediction without reasoningMissing
Own case and limitsA fitting new case and a real limit of the analogyA fitting new caseA case with surface similarity onlyMissing

Why this lesson

Documented

Business students who compared two negotiation cases were nearly three times as likely to use the strategy in their own negotiation as students who studied the same cases one at a time.

The experiments were with adult business students learning negotiation strategies. The finding that comparing two cases helps transfer has been repeated in other settings, but this lesson itself has not been tested.

Adjust it

Younger students: Grades 6–7: use pictures for the warehouse and the hallway, give the principle as three word choices to pick from, and do Case C as a whole class.

Older students: Ask students to find a pair of cases in their other classes this week (science, history, sport) and bring them in.

No devices at all? Skip the Partner step. Instead, the teacher reads two extra examples aloud (a highway on-ramp with a traffic light; a single checkout on a busy website) and the class votes: same bones or not?

The AI step

Level 2 AI as feedback

Optional and short. Use it on the teacher’s screen as a red team: it critiques, it does not decide. Prompt:

Here is a principle my class wrote: [principle]. Give me two real-world examples from different fields that share this exact structure, and one example that looks similar but does not.

Exit ticket

Write the principle you learned today and one place outside school where you have seen it.

Why this is hard to cheat

The cases are written for this lesson. Students map parts and apply the idea to their own case in class, so there is no single answer to copy.

Go further

Same Bones lab →

Honest limits and sources

Where this comes from

Open the source before quoting it.

Honest limits

What this page leaves out

This is an initial edition, written by ARQIV in October 2026. It has not been classroom-piloted or independently reviewed, so its scenarios and timings may change after classroom use. The evidence named above supports the core move of the lesson, not this lesson as a whole. We do not claim the lesson measures or certifies a student’s judgment or “learning agility.”

Review status

Written by ARQIV. Initial edition, October 2026. This lesson has not been classroom-piloted or independently reviewed yet, and every question and scenario is hand-authored and checked against its sources by ARQIV. Tell us about anything wrong or unclear.

  1. Jeffrey Loewenstein, Leigh Thompson and Dedre Gentner, "Analogical encoding facilitates knowledge transfer in negotiation," Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 6(4), 1999; see also Gentner, Loewenstein and Thompson, Journal of Educational Psychology 95(2), 2003.

All links opened and checked October 21, 2026 (accessed October 2026).