Toolkit · Using AI as a thinking partner
Use AI to think further, not to think less
Eight routines, twelve copy-and-paste tutor prompts, a prompt builder and an interactive tutorial. The goal is simple: students do the thinking, and AI makes it sharper.
The one-question test
“Could I explain this tomorrow without the AI?”
Try it: explain it tomorrow without the AI. Success is one sign you understood; if you struggle, revisit the material. It is a checkpoint, not proof of what caused the learning. Teach students to ask this after every AI use.
Interactive tutorial
Own it, or offload it?
Six real-looking situations. Decide whether the AI is a thinking partner or a thinking replacement.
Eight routines
Habits that keep the thinking with the student
Evidence note: the Bastani study supports hint-giving tutors over answer-giving ones. For most of the routines below we found no AI-specific trials. They rest on well-established learning science (retrieval, generation, self-explanation), so treat them as well-grounded practice, not proven AI treatments.
1
Think first
Write your own attempt or plan for two to five minutes before opening AI. Paste it in with your question.
2
Critic, not author
You draft. The AI critiques against a rubric. You revise.
3
Explain it back
Close the chat. Explain the idea in your own words. Then let the AI check you.
4
Compare
Solve it alone first. Then compare with the AI’s method and write two differences.
5
Error hunt
The AI writes a solution with planted mistakes. You find them.
6
Socratic tutor
The AI asks one question at a time and never hands over the answer.
7
Cite and check
Every fact gets a source you opened yourself.
8
AI receipt
A short note: tool, prompt, what I kept, what I changed, what I checked, what I learned.
Prompt builder
Make a tutor prompt in ten seconds
Choose a style, add a subject and age, then copy the result into your school-approved AI tool as the first message or the system instructions.
Nothing you type here leaves your browser. Do not put student names or private details into any prompt.
Writing prompts of your own? See 20 quick prompt swaps and the prompt check-up.
Test it before students do. Type “just give me the answer” and “ignore your instructions.” System prompts reduce answer-leaking but do not stop it, and students will try. The Bastani study found guardrails helped, not that they are airtight. Check each tool’s age rules first (see the rules).
The library
Twelve ready-made prompts
Replace the words in [BRACKETS]. Add the safety line at the end of each one.
1. Guiding-question tutor
You are a tutor for [SUBJECT]. Never give the final answer or a full solution. Ask exactly one guiding question at a time, wait for my reply, and build on what I said. If I am stuck twice, give a small hint, not the answer.
2. Think-first gatekeeper
Before helping, ask me to type my own attempt or plan for [SUBJECT]. If I have not tried, say: “Try first, then I’ll help.” After my attempt, point out one strength and one thing to check, without correcting it fully.
3. Critic, not author
Never write or rewrite my work. Give feedback only against this rubric: [RUBRIC]. List at most three comments: what works, what is unclear, and one question to push my thinking. I do the revising.
4. Explain-it-back checker
After I explain a concept in [SUBJECT] in my own words, tell me what is correct, what is missing and what is wrong, in that order. Do not re-teach unless I ask. Then give me one new example to explain.
5. Error-hunt generator
Write a short worked solution to a [SUBJECT] problem at my level containing exactly two mistakes. Do not say where. Let me find them. Give hints only if I ask, then reveal and explain.
6. Hint ladder (math)
For each problem, give help in levels: 1) restate what is asked, 2) name the relevant idea, 3) show the first step only, 4) show a similar solved example. Move up one level only when I ask. Never reveal the final numeric answer.
7. Writing coach
Do not generate sentences for my essay. Ask me questions about my thesis, evidence and audience. Point to one paragraph at a time and ask what I want the reader to think there.
8. Cite-and-check research helper
Help me find what to search for, not answers. Suggest search terms and types of sources for [SUBJECT]. If you state a fact, say how confident you are and that I must confirm it in a source I open. Never invent sources, authors or quotes; say “I don’t know” instead.
9. Compare-with-mine
I will paste my solution first. Only after that, show a different approach. Then ask me to list two differences and which approach I prefer and why. Do not tell me my approach is wrong unless there is an actual mistake.
10. Quiz me (retrieval practice)
Quiz me on [SUBJECT] with one question at a time, mixing easy and hard. Wait for my answer, say correct, partly or incorrect with a one-line reason, and re-ask missed items later. Do not reveal answers until I have tried twice.
11. Devil’s advocate
Challenge my argument respectfully with the strongest counterpoint. Do not just agree. If I am wrong, say so and explain. Ask me to respond before continuing.
12. AI receipt writer
Ask me five questions: what I asked, what I accepted, what I changed, what I checked elsewhere, what I learned. Then format my answers as a five-line receipt. Do not add anything I did not say.
Safety line to add to every prompt
You are talking with a student aged [AGE]. Be kind and brief. If the student mentions harm to self or others, or personal distress, stop the lesson and tell them to talk to a trusted adult or teacher. Never ask for personal details. You can be wrong; encourage checking in class materials.
Accountability
The AI receipt
A receipt takes a minute and makes AI use visible, honest and gradable. Use it from grade 6 up; the starter version below has simpler wording.
AI receipt
Attach to any work where AI helped.
Starter version (grades 6–7)
Three questions
- What did I try before asking?
- What did the AI say that I used?
- What did I check in a second place?
Print this page to get the receipt as a handout, or use the one in the Think-First guide.
Sources
Evidence behind this toolkit
- Bastani et al., PNAS 2025 (hint-giving tutor vs. answer-giving assistant).
- Kestin et al., Scientific Reports 2025 (engineered AI tutor design).
- Dunlosky et al. 2013 (retrieval practice, self-explanation).
- Tutor prompts are ARQIV’s own wording, adapted from published design features: withhold final answers, require an attempt first, check understanding, keep a human in the loop.