Free lesson · Grades 6–8 · 20 minutes · teacher-led · devices optional
Problem First: The Bus Challenge
A complete introductory lesson in checking a confident answer. Free, with the teacher key, and no signup.
FreeNo signupGrades 6–820 minutes
The problem
127 students and 11 adults travel on buses. Each bus has 48 passenger seats; the driver has a separate seat. Everyone must have a passenger seat. Buses cost $240 each. The transport budget is $750. How many buses are required, and does that fit the budget?
| Goal | Solve independently, detect an invalid interpretation of a calculation, and verify a revised answer against constraints. |
|---|---|
| Materials | Student pages 1–2 (printed or on a device), pencil or accessible alternative. A calculator is optional. Optional: the free mini-demo. |
| Preparation | Print the student pages. Keep this teacher plan and key separate. |
Sequence (20 minutes)
| Phase | Minutes | What happens | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ponder | 3 | Present the scenario and ask for an independent estimate before showing any prepared answer. Learners record a first attempt in writing, typing, drawing or speech. | Initial estimate, calculation, reason |
| Plan | 3 | Name the constraints: passengers, seats, whole buses, budget. The driver has a separate seat. Choose how to verify. | Constraint checklist |
| Partner | 3 | Reveal the constructed answer after first attempts. Learners mark each statement agree / question / check. | Annotated answer |
| Probe | 7 | Test 2, 3 and 4 buses with independent arithmetic (or the mini-demo). Explain seating and budget before showing the key. | Verification table; explanation of the rounding error |
| Prove | 4 | Exit explanation: how did you check the answer without asking an AI? | Final reasoning |
| Total | 20 |
Budget is an optional follow-up if arithmetic would overwhelm the introduction. For a full 45- or 60-minute version with a transfer assessment, see Classroom Studio.
Teacher key (free; open when you are ready)
Teacher key
| Buses | Capacity | Short by | Unused seats | Cost | Budget | Seating | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | 96 | 42 | 0 | $480 | within | insufficient | not feasible |
| 3 | 144 | 0 | 6 | $720 | within | sufficient | feasible |
| 4 | 192 | 0 | 54 | $960 | over | sufficient | not feasible |
| Statement | Note |
|---|---|
| 127 + 11 = 138 people. | Correct. The addition is right: 127 + 11 = 138. |
| 138 ÷ 48 = 2.875, which rounds down to 2 buses. | The division is right (2.875) but rounding DOWN is the error. A fractional bus cannot carry the remaining people; round up to 3. |
| Two buses cost $480, so the trip fits the budget. | The cost is arithmetically right ($480), but the conclusion rests on a plan that seats only 96 of 138 people, so it is infeasible. |
Watch for
- Rounding to the nearest whole number gives 3 here, but that is not the rule. Any leftover people need one more whole bus, even a small remainder (97 people on 48-seat buses still need 3 buses).
- A correct calculation can still support a wrong conclusion if the interpretation is wrong.
- The driver’s seat is separate; do not subtract it from passenger seats or add the driver to passengers.
- Passing the budget check does not make a plan feasible if the seating check fails.
- The capacity checker is a verification aid, not a live AI tool.
Accessible response options
- Estimate and explain by writing, typing, drawing or speaking.
- Use a number line or manipulatives for the seat count; no task requires dragging.
- Score the thinking, not handwriting or speech fluency; offer another opportunity for missing work.
Exit explanation exemplars (labeled examples)
| Level | Example | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Strong | Two buses seat 96, but 138 people need seats, so 42 would have no seat. Three buses seat 144 and cost $720, which is $30 under budget. The constructed answer rounded down, which breaks the seating rule. I checked by multiplying 3 × 48. | Independent attempt, applies the capacity calculation, names the error and states what was verified. |
| Developing | It should be 3 because 2 isn’t enough. | Correct revision, but the reason is incomplete: it does not say how “not enough” was checked. |
| Incomplete | (Copies “3 buses” with no work shown.) | Final claim copied without explanation. Offer another opportunity. |
Review status: arithmetic, source mapping and time totals are checked by ARQIV, with automated tests. The materials have not been classroom-tested. All examples are authored; none is a live AI result.
Print and download
The student pages below print on their own. The teacher plan and key are separate.
Problem First: The Bus Challenge
My estimate (before calculating):
My calculation and what I think the answer is:
Constraints checklist
| Constraint | My numbers |
|---|---|
| How many people need seats? | |
| How many passenger seats on one bus? | |
| Can I use part of a bus? | |
| What does one bus cost? What is the budget? |
How will I check a plan?
Check the answer
This answer was written to contain a mistake so we can practise checking. It is not a result from any AI product.
| Statement | I agree / I question / I need to check | My notes |
|---|---|---|
| 127 + 11 = 138 people. | ||
| 138 ÷ 48 = 2.875, which rounds down to 2 buses. | ||
| Two buses cost $480, so the trip fits the budget. |
Verification table
| Buses | Seats (buses × 48) | People without a seat | Unused seats | Cost | Seating OK? | Budget OK? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | ||||||
| 3 | ||||||
| 4 |
My explanation: what was wrong with the constructed answer, and what is the right plan?
Want more?
Find a free starting activity for every grade band, or browse every free kit, lesson and printable.