Free lesson · Grades 6–8 · 20 minutes · teacher-led · devices optional

Problem First: The Bus Challenge

A complete introductory lesson in checking a confident answer. Free, with the teacher key, and no signup.

Print the student pagesTry the five-step preview

FreeNo signupGrades 6–820 minutes

Honesty note. The “AI-style” answer is authored to contain an error. It is not a captured result from any named AI. Nothing you do on this page is saved or sent.

The problem

127 students and 11 adults travel on buses. Each bus has 48 passenger seats; the driver has a separate seat. Everyone must have a passenger seat. Buses cost $240 each. The transport budget is $750. How many buses are required, and does that fit the budget?

GoalSolve independently, detect an invalid interpretation of a calculation, and verify a revised answer against constraints.
MaterialsStudent pages 1–2 (printed or on a device), pencil or accessible alternative. A calculator is optional. Optional: the free mini-demo.
PreparationPrint the student pages. Keep this teacher plan and key separate.

Sequence (20 minutes)

PhaseMinutesWhat happensEvidence
Ponder3Present the scenario and ask for an independent estimate before showing any prepared answer. Learners record a first attempt in writing, typing, drawing or speech.Initial estimate, calculation, reason
Plan3Name the constraints: passengers, seats, whole buses, budget. The driver has a separate seat. Choose how to verify.Constraint checklist
Partner3Reveal the constructed answer after first attempts. Learners mark each statement agree / question / check.Annotated answer
Probe7Test 2, 3 and 4 buses with independent arithmetic (or the mini-demo). Explain seating and budget before showing the key.Verification table; explanation of the rounding error
Prove4Exit explanation: how did you check the answer without asking an AI?Final reasoning
Total20

Budget is an optional follow-up if arithmetic would overwhelm the introduction. For a full 45- or 60-minute version with a transfer assessment, see Classroom Studio.

SayYou will solve this before you see any answer. Then we will check a confident answer against the rules of the problem.
Teacher key (free; open when you are ready)

Teacher key

Teacher key127 + 11 = 138 passengers. 138 ÷ 48 = 2.875, so round UP to 3 buses. 3 × 48 = 144 seats, 6 unused. 3 × $240 = $720, which is $30 under the $750 budget. Two buses give 96 seats and leave 42 people without a seat.
BusesCapacityShort byUnused seatsCostBudgetSeatingOverall
296420$480withininsufficientnot feasible
314406$720withinsufficientfeasible
4192054$960oversufficientnot feasible
StatementNote
127 + 11 = 138 people.Correct. The addition is right: 127 + 11 = 138.
138 ÷ 48 = 2.875, which rounds down to 2 buses.The division is right (2.875) but rounding DOWN is the error. A fractional bus cannot carry the remaining people; round up to 3.
Two buses cost $480, so the trip fits the budget.The cost is arithmetically right ($480), but the conclusion rests on a plan that seats only 96 of 138 people, so it is infeasible.

Watch for

  • Rounding to the nearest whole number gives 3 here, but that is not the rule. Any leftover people need one more whole bus, even a small remainder (97 people on 48-seat buses still need 3 buses).
  • A correct calculation can still support a wrong conclusion if the interpretation is wrong.
  • The driver’s seat is separate; do not subtract it from passenger seats or add the driver to passengers.
  • Passing the budget check does not make a plan feasible if the seating check fails.
  • The capacity checker is a verification aid, not a live AI tool.

Accessible response options

  • Estimate and explain by writing, typing, drawing or speaking.
  • Use a number line or manipulatives for the seat count; no task requires dragging.
  • Score the thinking, not handwriting or speech fluency; offer another opportunity for missing work.

Exit explanation exemplars (labeled examples)

LevelExampleNote
StrongTwo buses seat 96, but 138 people need seats, so 42 would have no seat. Three buses seat 144 and cost $720, which is $30 under budget. The constructed answer rounded down, which breaks the seating rule. I checked by multiplying 3 × 48.Independent attempt, applies the capacity calculation, names the error and states what was verified.
DevelopingIt should be 3 because 2 isn’t enough.Correct revision, but the reason is incomplete: it does not say how “not enough” was checked.
Incomplete(Copies “3 buses” with no work shown.)Final claim copied without explanation. Offer another opportunity.

Review status: arithmetic, source mapping and time totals are checked by ARQIV, with automated tests. The materials have not been classroom-tested. All examples are authored; none is a live AI result.

Print and download

The student pages below print on their own. The teacher plan and key are separate.

Student pages (PDF)Teacher plan and key (PDF)Student pages (Word)Teacher plan (Word)

Problem First: The Bus Challenge

Name (optional)Date
The problem127 students and 11 adults travel on buses. Each bus has 48 passenger seats; the driver has a separate seat. Everyone must have a passenger seat. Buses cost $240 each. The transport budget is $750. How many buses are required, and does that fit the budget?

My estimate (before calculating):

My calculation and what I think the answer is:

Constraints checklist

ConstraintMy numbers
How many people need seats?
How many passenger seats on one bus?
Can I use part of a bus?
What does one bus cost? What is the budget?

How will I check a plan?

Check the answer

A constructed answer (not from a real AI)127 + 11 = 138 people. 138 ÷ 48 = 2.875, which rounds down to 2 buses. Two buses cost $480, so the trip fits the budget.

This answer was written to contain a mistake so we can practise checking. It is not a result from any AI product.

StatementI agree / I question / I need to checkMy notes
127 + 11 = 138 people.
138 ÷ 48 = 2.875, which rounds down to 2 buses.
Two buses cost $480, so the trip fits the budget.

Verification table

BusesSeats (buses × 48)People without a seatUnused seatsCostSeating OK?Budget OK?
2
3
4

My explanation: what was wrong with the constructed answer, and what is the right plan?

Want more?

Find a free starting activity for every grade band, or browse every free kit, lesson and printable.

Activities by gradeAll free resources